Let Us Help You Find the Perfect Stone for Your Fireplace Surround

This time of year, there is nothing more appealing than cozying up in front of the fireplace with a good book. If your fireplace could use an upgrade, Garrity Stone, Inc. is here to help! With four acres of natural stone in stock, our team will help you find the right stone to create the perfect fireplace surround.

Stone Products for Fireplace Surround

Things to Consider

Fireplace design is a personal decision, and there are many factors that should be taken into consideration. Think about your home’s style and decor, and decide if you want your fireplace to have a modern or rustic appeal. Also consider whether you want a homogenous look, or a lot of texture and color variations. You should also consider the level of maintenance each stone requires and what you are willing and able to put up with, as regular cleaning, sealing, and mortar repairs are all part of owning a natural stone fireplace. And last, but not least, keep your budget in mind as the cost of stone varies greatly.

Popular Choices:


Many people like limestone because it is versatile, durable, and affordable. Limestone comes in a variety of colors and patterns, making it easy to match your home’s style and decor. Furthermore, limestone can be installed in slabs for a clean, smooth look or stacked for a rustic appeal. Limestone is heat-resistant and durable, but it does require regular sealing to prevent staining over time. 


Sandstone is another great option for a natural stone fireplace surround. If you use your fireplace as a heat source, sandstone is a great addition because it retains heat for a long time. Sandstone is durable, easy to clean, and comes in a range of earthy tones.


For a contemporary look, granite is the way to go. Like sandstone and limestone, granite is porous and requires sealing to keep it from staining. Granite, though, is easy to clean, durable, and extremely heat-resistant. Granite also comes in a wide variety of shades and patterns, and will retain its natural color for years.

We Are Here to Help

The best way to choose the right stone for your fireplace is to visit our lot in Fishers. As the primary stone provider of Indianapolis since 1964, we will help you select the right stone to meet your needs and budget. For more information, contact us today at (317) 546-0893.